« Blunt Instrument | Main | The Cure for Junk Patents: Old Hat »

January 25, 2006

Nellcor Bites The Bullet

Facing a permanent injunction, and so biting the patent infringement bullet that delusional RIM (v. NTP) still thinks it can miraculously dodge, Nellcor, a division of Tyco Healthcare, itself a subsidiary of industrial conglomerate Tyco International, has agreed to fork over $330 million for infringing medical device patents owned by privately-held mighty mouse Masimo.

With the payout, Nellcor gets a patent license to continue selling its pulse oximeter and airway management products, in exchange for paying ongoing royalties. Oximeters measure oxygen blood levels.

Masimo's patents in the case, 5,769,785, 6,157,850, 6,206,830, & 6,263,222, detail signal processing methods improving oximetry reading accuracy.

The court proceedings had been dramatic. The jury found for Masimo on all four patents in a six-week trial, but then the district court found one patent unenforceable due to inequitable conduct, reversed the jury verdict of infringement for one patent, and reversed willfulness on the other two. Tyco had countersued with its own patent assertion, but that didn't cut the ice. Damages were set at $134.5, which survived appeal review. Being sent back to the district court for a permanent injunction, Tyco decided it was time to settle up and get on with business, paying $265 million for damages and $65 million in advance royalties.

U.S. Surgical, another Tyco subsidiary, just lost a patent infringement case brought by Applied Medical. When it rains it pours.

Posted by Patent Hawk at January 25, 2006 1:59 PM | Litigation