« Claim Construction Black Hole | Main | Seedy »
August 15, 2006
Carded
In
a classic case of overreaching, E-Pass
Technologies was shot down for the second time for trying to pose a
multi-function electronic card, claimed in
5,276,311, as a personal digital assistant (PDA), first suing Palm
unsuccessfully, then Microsoft and HP. In the Southern District of Texas, Judge
Hoyt ruled in favor of Microsoft & HP, that PDAs were not "cards," that
non-infringement was so obvious as to be a matter of law, and thus granting
summary judgment.
Cluelessness unsurpassed by greed, E-Pass had sought an injunction and $210 million in damages. Clowns like this are going to give patents a bad reputation.
Posted by Patent Hawk at August 15, 2006 4:10 PM | Litigation