« On the Path to Obviousness | Main | Recapture »

October 12, 2006

Low Power

At the turn of the century, Silicon Valley debutante Transmeta shipped a low-power microprocessor, the Crusoe, a promising debut for the laptop and portable device market. The product promise was never realized. Intel's Pentium III shipped shortly before, making billions to Crusoe's millions. Now Transmeta claims Intel tucked into its Pentium Transmeta's patented technologies.

Transmeta filed in Delaware yesterday for infringement of ten patents: 5,737,624; 5,838,986; 5,895,503; 5,974,526; 6,044,449; 6,226,733; 6,289,433; 6,430,668; 6,813,699;  and 7,001,061.

In 2005, Transmeta, employing about 220 people, made $72.7 million; Intel, with more than 100,000 employees worldwide, grossed $32.82 billion.

Oddly, while Transmeta was x86 compatible, it never licensed any of Intel's patents. For a while, it was expected that Intel would go after Transmeta for infringement, but it never happened.

Transmeta has lost money for years: between 1998 and 2005, it lost $635 million on revenues of $134. It has been a venture capitalist's nightmare. Transmeta is expected to post a loss of $16-$26 million for the past fiscal year. Patent royalty payment would be just the financial fillip it needs.

Transmeta started up in 1995. David Ditzel, a co-founder, was a chip wunderkind at Sun Microsystems. Linus Torvalds, an early developer of Linux, was on staff for awhile.

This is not likely a case to ever see trial. Intel has too much at stake, and too little, on balance, to counterclaim effectively.

Posted by Patent Hawk at October 12, 2006 4:17 PM | Litigation