« Low Blow to MoFo | Main | Potato Row to be Hoed in Seattle »
April 14, 2009
Star Crossed
In
2001, smokeless tobacco maker Star Scientific sued R.J. Reynolds over patents
for lower carcinogens while curing tobacco. Maryland district court Judge Marvin
Garbis found Star
guilty of
inequitable conduct. In a landmark ruling, the
CAFC overturned.
Then, in hopes of further delay, RJR tried to put the patents out to pasture on
reexam. But
trial is set for May 18, while the reexam smolders on. The most recent curveball
from RJR: a motion to deny Star a chance to present its damages theory to the
jury.
Financially, Star has been smokeless for quite some time. Last year it lost $18 million on sales of $ one-half million. But investors have invested, hoping to smoke RJR with patents that might cure Star. The Wall Street Journal -
With just $500,000 of the nearly $5 billion smokeless-tobacco market, Star is too tiny to have attracted much attention from independent financial analysts. But after researching the company, some fund managers have invested nearly $100 million in Star to prop it up amid the legal battle. "It's a small company with a Fortune 100 legal team and some very, very promising intellectual property," says Robert W. Scannell, a partner in Tradewinds Investment Management in Sausalito, Calif.
The trial is just the next chapter. Whoever prevails, the case will be on offer for another chew by the appeals court.
Posted by Patent Hawk at April 14, 2009 11:42 PM | Litigation