« Enablement Out of Order | Main | Recall »

March 28, 2014

Making It Up

Patent subject matter eligibility under 35 USC §101 has been clarified by the Supreme Court in recent years. In providing new guidance to examiners, USPTO management decided to ignore the law and inventively go their own way. The guidance criteria has an examiner ask whether a claim is "significantly different" than "judicial exceptions." Such "exceptions" to patentability (i.e., cannot be patented) are "abstract ideas, laws of nature/natural principles, natural phenomena, and natural products." Explaining what "significantly different" means is well elaborated. But the upshot is that for years to come, patents will be denied or granted based upon criteria that are not well rooted in law. In other words, business as usual at the patent office.

Posted by Patent Hawk at March 28, 2014 2:36 PM | The Patent Office